Elkhorn Pizzeria

"Amazing pizza. Great crust and toppings. Staff and service great! Go early, we went at 5 pm on a Saturday...by 530 people were lined up out the door. We had the meat lovers, Caesar salad, and pepperoni pizza. All SO GOOD!"

"Pizza and wings are amazing. Friendly staff and cool place with other options such as subs and cold beer. Only complaint is a bit hot inside. I know the ovens make it hot. But been there twice and both times experience was exceptional. Oh and gluten free dough is "bussin" according to my teen! Must try!"

"Place an order on line for a Hawaiian pizza, not sure if I made a mistake or the restaurant did, I discovered the pizza had no tomato sauce after I brought it back. The pineapple pieces also appeared to be put on after the pizza was baked because they were all falling off from the pizza. Other than that, the pizza tasted fine but not outstanding. I got a call from the restaurant after I posted the review. They offered to remake my pizza to make it right. I already ate the one I got so I turned it down. Any time a business take initiative to correct a mistake (in this case it could have been my mistake), it deserves a five star."

"Looking for that old school jazz lounge? What about watching cats play that jazz? Now ask yourself what would make all that better, if this place served pizza! Well folks this place exists in Buena Vista, CO! Ok may not be an old school lounge but does have cars playing jazz music and excellent pizza!!! Mom & Son were working we went in, they were great. Was fun to watch them work together. Reminds me of my home town pizza joint in Tx. The cats playing jazz on tv was very fun. Found a new channel for my step-dad and dogs. Pizza - ordered their L meat lovers and fried dough. Pizza was ON POINT. Their sauces to cheese to meat was perfect. Not too little, not too much. Crust stayed crispy on the bottom but on the top soaked in the sauce. The meat and mozzarella they used had a good savory salty taste where you could actually taste each item. Fried dough was a great finisher. We ordered L pizza, fried dough, bottle coke & bottle water = $40 - $45 We will be back, only live 2 hrs away and worth the drive."

"Fantastic pizza! A great find in Buena Vista. Loved the laid back atmosphere and friendly staff. Good GF pizza!"

"Passing through with a hankering for pizza. After weighing the options we decided to give this a shot. At first I was skeptical of my choice, but honestly? The pizza was by far the best pizza we have had in a long time! We have 8 kids and eat pizza pretty often so... well done! It is very eclectic and eccentric. From menu options... from Pho to Pizza... to beans as a sauce option. Then you have late 90s elevator music playing loud while a game is on one TV and the Simpsons is playing on another. The decor is... I'm not really sure. The buildings bones give a great pizzeria vibe, I wish they would run with it! The mural as you walked in could be extended and while the tables and bar are pretty epoxy/wood tables they could spiced up to match better. Overall experience was positive. Great food ! Will definitely go back again!"

"Drove down to Buena Vista, CO.. for pizza as Half Moon Pies in Leadville was closed... it is a weekday in November... ELKHORN PIZZA..... is LITERALLY THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD!!!!!! And... I'm a thin crust sausage and mushroom Chicago pizza girl..... This place will be on my list of... Must stop here... from now until.... forever...... "